Influence of mouth guards on autonomic nervous system activities: A quantitative study of pupillary flash responses

BackgroundRecently, it has been reported that mouth guards (MGs), which reduce the incidence and severity of traumatic oral injuries in contact sports, may actually affect sports performance. We have observed that a majority of subjects showed improved dynamic visual acuity during head rotation when using a MG, but subjects who were unwilling to use a MG showed the opposite effect. Thus, we hypothesized that unpleasant sensations due to MGs may decrease sports performance.MethodsIn this study, we measured autonomic nervous system activity to evaluate unpleasant sensations objectively and quantitatively by measuring the pupillary flash response (PFR) and heart rate variability (HRV), before, during, and after wearing 3- and 5-mm-thick custom-made MGs in 10 healthy subjects.ResultsIt was found that the 5-mm MG had a higher incidence of unpleasant sensations (50% of subjects) than did the 3-mm MG (10%). PFR (not HRV) analysis showed that both sympathetic and parasympathetic nervous system activities increased in subjects with unpleasant sensations.ConclusionsWe suggest that the unpleasant sensation induced this unusual autonomic nervous system response, which could not be detected by traditional methods such as HRV analysis. By using PFR analysis, it is possible to make MGs without unpleasant sensations for better sports performance.

▸ Our previous data showed that subjects who were unwilling to use a mouth guard (MG) did not improve dynamic visual acuity. ▸ We hypothesize that unpleasant sensation due to a MG may decrease sports performance. ▸ Autonomic nervous system activity (ANSA) is measured to evaluate unpleasant sensations objectively and quantitatively. ▸ The pupillary flash response is more sensitive to changes in ANSA than heart rate variability. ▸ Both sympathetic and parasympathetic nervous system activities increase in the subject with unpleasant sensation due to a MG.