Craniectomy and noggin application in an infant model

SummaryIntroductionNoggin is an antagonist of bone morphogenetic proteins (BMP)-2, -4 and -7. Little data are available regarding its clinical utility. Two hypotheses were put forward: firstly, that spontaneous regeneration of calvarial defects with noggin protein would result in diminished bone volume when compared with calvarial defects not so treated. Secondly, that centrifugal cranial expansion would remain undisturbed whether noggin was applied or not.Material and methodsA unilateral defect of the frontal and parietal bones (2×4 cm) was generated by excising the right coronal suture in 2-month-old minipigs (n=10) and in group 1 (n=5) no further intervention was undertaken. In the second group (n=5), a collagen type I tissue fleece and noggin protein (1.05 mg/ml) were applied. After 4 months the coronal suture regions of frontal sides were examined in each animal by computed tomography and non-decalcified histology.ResultsBony gaps of equivalent size remained in animals of both groups. The differences in bone volumes of the experimental sides of group 1 were not statistically significantly different (p=0.117) when compared with those of group 2. A significant difference in the bone volumes of the experimental versus control (unoperated) sides was found in both group 1 (p=0.043) and group 2 (p=0.043). Internal skull diameters increased by 16.4% in both groups but the physiological centrifugal cranial expansion remained undisturbed. Bone densities of the experimental and control sides of groups 1 and 2 were not statistically significantly different (both p>0.05).ConclusionsThe first hypothesis was contradicted: the quantity and quality of spontaneous bone regenerates was not altered by application of noggin protein. The second hypothesis was confirmed: no disruption of subsequent cranial development was seen. It may be that a single application of noggin protein in this study was insufficient. However, it may well be suggested that the continuous supplementation of noggin, for example by adenoviral noggin gene transfer may significantly reduce the quantity of spontaneous bone regeneration in a similar experiment.