Registration of 3-Dimensional Facial Photographs for Clinical Use

PurposeTo objectively evaluate treatment outcomes in oral and maxillofacial surgery, pre- and post-treatment 3-dimensional (3D) photographs of the patient's face can be registered. For clinical use, it is of great importance that this registration process is accurate (< 1 mm). The purpose of this study was to determine the accuracy of different registration procedures.Materials and MethodsFifteen volunteers (7 males, 8 females; mean age, 23.6 years; range, 21 to 26 years) were invited to participate in this study. Three-dimensional photographs were captured at 3 different times: baseline (T0), after 1 minute (T1), and 3 weeks later (T2). Furthermore, a 3D photograph of the volunteer laughing (TL) was acquired to investigate the effect of facial expression. Two different registration methods were used to register the photographs acquired at all different times: surface-based registration and reference-based registration. Within the surface-based registration, 2 different software packages (Maxilim [Medicim NV, Mechelen, Belgium] and 3dMD Patient [3dMD LLC, Atlanta, GA]) were used to register the 3D photographs acquired at the various times. The surface-based registration process was repeated with the preprocessed photographs. Reference-based registration (Maxilim) was performed twice by 2 observers investigating the inter- and intraobserver error.ResultsThe mean registration errors are small for the 3D photographs at rest (0.39 mm for T0-T1 and 0.52 mm for T0-T2). The mean registration error increased to 1.2 mm for the registration between the 3D photographs acquired at T0 and TL. The mean registration error for the reference-based method was 1.0 mm for T0-T1, 1.1 mm for T0-T2, and 1.5 mm for T0 and TL. The mean registration errors for the preprocessed photographs were even smaller (0.30 mm for T0-T1, 0.42 mm for T0-T2, and 1.2 mm for T0 and TL). Furthermore, a strong correlation between the results of both software packages used for surface-based registration was found. The intra- and interobserver error for the reference-based registration method was found to be 1.2 and 1.0 mm, respectively.ConclusionSurface-based registration is an accurate method to compare 3D photographs of the same individual at different times. When performing the registration procedure with the preprocessed photographs, the registration error decreases. No significant difference could be found between both software packages that were used to perform surface-based registration.