Are we following the guiding SIGN when managing paediatric head injury?

Background and AimsThe Scottish Intercollegiate Guidelines Network (SIGN) has published guidelines for the management of children with head injuries. The management of children with head injuries admitted to our local unit under the Paediatric Surgeons has been audited to determine whether or not current practice follows SIGN recommendations.MethodsData were collected retrospectively from the case records of patients admitted between January and December 2007. The SIGN guideline ‘Early Management of Patients with a Head Injury’ (Guideline 46) was published in 2000 and updated in 2009 (Guideline 110). Head injury admission practices were audited against both guidelines.ResultsThe case records of 200 patients were analysed. According to SIGN Guideline 46 (2000), 146 Computed Tomography (CT) scans were indicated but only 24 were performed (16%). The updated Guideline 110 (2009) suggests a CT scan was indicated in 24 patients and should have been considered in a further 87. However, only 12 (50%) and 18 (21%) patients were imaged in these respective groups. Both guidelines indicated neurosurgical review in 13 patients but sought in only 4 (31%). 50 patients were deemed to have suffered a significant head injury warranting follow-up, but this was arranged in only 14 (28%).ConclusionsOur study has identified that management of paediatric head injuries in our unit is reliant on clinical acumen rather than the SIGN guidelines when making decisions regarding the need for imaging, neurosurgical review and follow-up. We suggest further investigation is required to determine whether greater awareness and closer adherence with the guidelines would alter clinical outcomes.