Evaluation of the World Health Organization's family planning decision-making tool: Improving health communication in Nicaragua

ObjectiveThe World Health Organization has led the development of a Decision-Making Tool for Family Planning Clients and Providers (DMT) to improve the quality of family planning counseling. This study investigates the DMT's impact on health communication in Nicaragua.MethodsFifty nine service providers in Nicaragua were videotaped with 426 family planning clients 3 months before and 4 months after attending a training workshop on the DMT. The videotapes were coded for both provider and client communication.ResultsAfter the intervention providers increased their efforts to identify and respond to client needs, involve clients in the decision-making process, and screen for and educate new clients about the chosen method. While the DMT had a smaller impact on clients than providers, in general clients did become more forthcoming about their situation and their wishes. The DMT had a greater impact on sessions in which clients chose a new contraceptive method, as compared with visits by returning clients for a check-up or resupply.ConclusionThe DMT proved effective both as a job aid for providers and a decision-making aid for clients, regardless of the client's level of education.Practice implicationsJob and decision-making aids have the potential to improve health communication, even or especially when clients have limited education and providers have limited training and supervision.