The Effect of Notchplasty on Tunnel Widening in Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction

PurposeTo investigate changes in femoral tunnel diameter, dimension, and volume after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with notchplasty.MethodsPorcine knee specimens were divided into 2 groups of 10 specimens each. Group A did not receive notchplasty. A 2-mm notchplasty was conducted in group B. Seven-millimeter-diameter femoral tunnels were drilled and a doubled flexor digitorum profundus tendon was inserted and fixed with an EndoButton (Smith & Nephew, Andover, MA) in each knee specimen. Samples were mounted on a materials testing machine. Each group was preloaded at 10 N and subjected to 20 loading cycles (between 0 and 40 N), followed by 1,000 loading cycles in the elastic region (between 10 and 150 N). High-resolution computed tomography with 1.0-mm slices was conducted with all samples before and after testing. A 3-dimensional model was constructed to evaluate the degree of the tunnel change.ResultsIn group B the mean longest diameter and dimension of the femoral tunnel significantly increased after the test (P = .005 and P = .001, respectively). The volumetric loss of bony structure after the test in group B was significantly greater than that in group A (P = .039). Meanwhile, no significant difference was found before and after the test in terms of tunnel diameter, dimension, and volumetric loss around the tunnel in group A.ConclusionsThe intra-articular orifice of the femoral tunnel was enlarged after the uniaxial cyclic loading test after notchplasty. An enlarged tunnel orifice may lead to a discrepancy between the tunnel and the graft at the tunnel aperture.Clinical RelevanceThe data may have an implication that suspensory fixation with a notchplasty has a negative effect on the full graft accommodation at the tunnel aperture. Aperture widening may affect graft positioning, leading to subtle changes in graft biomechanics and laxity.