In vivo hip joint loads during three methods of walking with forearm crutches

BackgroundPatients with osteoarthritis, joint implants or fractures use crutches in order to reduce lower limb loading. However, insufficient information exists on how much the loading is then in fact reduced. This situation was studied by using seven patients who had instrumented hip implants.MethodsPart I: To investigate the effectiveness of forearm crutches, crutch and hip joint contact forces were measured in seven patients with instrumented hip prostheses. Additionally, the bending moments in the implant neck and torsion around its stem were determined. Reductions of peak loads during 3, 4, and 2-point gaits were compared with loads present when walking without crutches.Part II: This examines joint load reduction during a 4-point gait from one to 12 weeks post-operatively.FindingsPart I: During a 3, 4, and 2-point gait, the joint force was 17, 12, and 13% lower than it was while walking without crutches. The corresponding reductions of the bending moment were 16, 11, and 12%, while the maximum torque decreased by 19, 21, and 10%.Part II: The reductions of contact forces in comparison with walking without crutches were highest during the first 4 weeks after surgery. One and 4 weeks post-operatively, the force maximum was 21 and 8% lower than it was after 3 months. When compared with the initial values of the 1st week, crutch forces decreased by 28% in the 4th week and by 38% in the 3rd month.InterpretationAverage reductions of the joint load by more than 20% are achieved only during the first 4 post-operative weeks. Because fractures are in most cases relatively stable after 6 weeks, and bone ingrowth into implant interfaces is nearly finished after this time, a single crutch and a 2-point gait can be prescribed during the 5th and 6th post-operative week.