Consensus Document on the Overlap Phenotype COPD–Asthma in COPD

IntroductionAlthough asthma and COPD are different pathologies, many patients share characteristics from both entities. These cases can have different evolutions and responses to treatment. Nevertheless, the evidence available is limited, and it is necessary to evaluate whether they represent a differential phenotype and provide recommendations about diagnosis and treatment, in addition to identifying possible gaps in our understanding of asthma and COPD.MethodsA nation-wide consensus of experts in COPD in two stages: (1) during an initial meeting, the topics to be dealt with were established and a first draft of statement was elaborated with a structured “brainstorming” method; (2) consensus was reached with two rounds of e-mails, using a Likert-type scale.ResultsConsensus was reached about the existence of a differential clinical phenotype known as “Overlap Phenotype COPD–Asthma”, whose diagnosis is made when 2 major criteria and 2 minor criteria are met. The major criteria include very positive bronchodilator test (increase in FEV1 ≥15% and ≥400 ml), eosinophilia in sputum and personal history of asthma. Minor criteria include high total IgE, personal history of atopy and positive bronchodilator test (increase in FEV1 ≥12% and ≥200 ml) on two or more occasions. The early use of individually adjusted inhaled corticosteroids is recommended, and caution must be taken with their abrupt withdrawal. Meanwhile, in severe cases the use of triple therapy should be evaluated. Finally, there is an obvious lack of specific studies about the natural history and the treatment of these patients.ConclusionsIt is necessary to expand our knowledge about this phenotype in order to establish adequate guidelines and recommendations for its diagnosis and treatment.

ResumenIntroducciónAunque asma y EPOC son enfermedades distintas, muchos pacientes comparten características de ambas entidades. Estos casos pueden tener una evolución y una respuesta al tratamiento diferente. Sin embargo, la evidencia disponible es escasa, y es necesario valorar si representan un fenotipo diferencial y aportar recomendaciones sobre su diagnóstico y tratamiento, además de identificar posibles lagunas de conocimiento.MétodoConsenso nacional de expertos en EPOC en dos etapas: 1) Se establecieron los bloques temáticos a tratar y se elaboró una primera propuesta de aseveraciones, mediante una reunión presencial con metodología de «tormenta de ideas» estructurada. 2) Se realizaron dos rondas de consenso vía correo electrónico, utilizando una escala tipo Likert.ResultadosSe consensua la existencia de un fenotipo clínico diferencial denominado «fenotipo mixto EPOC-asma», cuyo diagnóstico se realizará si se cumplen 2 criterios mayores o uno mayor y 2 menores (criterios mayores: prueba broncodilatadora muy positiva [aumento del FEV1 ≥ 15% y ≥ 400 ml], eosinofilia en esputo y antecedentes personales de asma; criterios menores: IgE total elevada, antecedentes personales de atopia y prueba broncodilatadora positiva [aumento del FEV1 ≥ 12% y ≥ 200 ml] en dos o más ocasiones). Se recomienda el uso precoz de corticoides inhalados (CI) ajustados individualmente, ser cautos con la retirada brusca de CI y, en casos graves, valorar el uso de la triple terapia. Finalmente, queda patente la falta de estudios específicos sobre la historia natural y el tratamiento de estos pacientes.ConclusionesEs preciso profundizar en el conocimiento de este fenotipo para establecer pautas y recomendaciones adecuadas para su diagnóstico y tratamiento.