Laparoscopic versus open left colectomy in patients with sigmoid colon cancer: Prospective cohort study with long-term follow-up

• The laparoscopic approach has revolutionized colon surgery.
• Laparoscopic colectomy is far from representing a common surgical practice.
• Not all the studies reporting long-term results permit a complete survival analysis.
• Studies do not perform sub-group analyses based on the location of the tumor.
• Need for trials to evaluate complications and long-term oncology results.

BackgroundLaparoscopic left colectomy has obtained a large spread in colon surgery for malignant disease despite the need for an adequate learning curve. However few studies reported long term data in comparison with open left colectomy and most of the authors of large series on colorectal surgery don't describe, in subgroup analysis, results obtained in left colonic resections.The aim of this study is to report the short and long term follow-up of laparoscopic left colon resection in comparison with the open approach, from a single centre, performed in the same timeframe.MethodsBetween January 2005 to January 2007, 55 patients with sigma adenocarcinoma underwent to laparoscopic or open left colectomy at the Department of Digestive Surgery, “S. Maria” hospital in Terni – Italy. Perioperative and histopathological data and results from oncological follow-up, until April 2013, are analyzed.Results28 patients underwent laparoscopic left colectomy, while 27 patients open left colectomy.Mean hospital stay was 8.44 ± 1.21 in the laparoscopic group versus 6.86 ± 1.01 in the open group.The histopathological analysis shows a mean of 18.13 ± 6.8 lymph nodes removed after laparoscopy and 13.96 ± 5.72 after open surgery (P = 0.02). Kaplan–Meier analysis does not reveal significative differences in disease free survival (HR = 0.85; 95% CI = 0.21–3.40; P = 0.81). Overall survival up to 5 years shows one death per group.ConclusionsLaparoscopy, respect to the open approach, could improve perioperative clinical outcomes, hospital stay and harvested lymph nodes with comparable long term oncological follow-up in patients with sigmoid colon cancer.