A comparative analysis of fine versus coarse taxonomic resolution in benthic chironomid community analyses

The analysis of sedimentary chironomid assemblages is an approach that has been widely adopted for inferring past environmental conditions. However, there is an ongoing discussion in the literature about whether this approach could become more sensitive at detecting past environmental changes if paleolimnologists conducted finer taxonomic analyses of their specimens. To advance this discussion, we conducted comparative analyses of larval chironomid assemblages resolved to two levels of taxonomic resolution. For this exercise, we chose to use live assemblages (as opposed to sub-fossil assemblages) because fine taxonomic resolution of live assemblages is more easily obtained. Our specific aims were to (i) determine if finely resolved taxa comprising a coarsely resolved group have similar ecological niches, (ii) determine if different environmental predictors of community composition are identified when two different levels of taxonomic resolution are applied and (iii) evaluate whether the variance explained by environmental variables differs substantially between levels of taxonomic resolution. We found that there was substantial dispersion among finely resolved taxa belonging to a single coarse group, which suggests that the merging of these taxa results in the loss of ecological information, and therefore warrants higher taxonomic precision. However, the identification of significant environmental predictors and the proportion of variance explained by these did not differ greatly between our two levels of taxonomic resolution. Overall our results show that coarse-resolution analyses may be adequate for some applications, but if the aim is to infer subtle environmental changes (as is the case in most paleolimnological studies) we recommend the highest possible level of taxonomic resolution.