Increased abundance, but reduced nest predation in the chestnut-backed antbird in costa rican rainforest fragments: surprising impacts of a pervasive snake species

• We studied nest predation rate and predators in a tropical understory bird.
• Predation rate was lowest in fragments and highest in a rainforest reserve.
• Snakes were the primary predators; one species, Pseustes, depredated 80% of nests.
• Habitat and predator identity affected nest predation, which may limit populations.
• Our results reveal context-dependent predation threats important to conservation.

Understory insectivorous birds often disappear from fragmented tropical rainforest landscapes before mechanisms such as increased rate of nest depredation can be evaluated. Here, we took advantage of chestnut-backed antbird (Myrmeciza exsul), a representative rainforest understory insectivore that persists in fragments (unlike many other understory species), to identify variables influencing nest predation rate and to test the hypothesis that nest predation underlies avian extirpation in tropical fragments. We compared nest predation rates, bird density, and predator identities in three habitats of lowland Caribbean Costa Rica: two fragments, a peninsular reserve (La Selva Biological Station), and unfragmented rainforest. Our results suggest an inversely density-dependent nest predation pattern: In fragments, chestnut-backed antbirds reached their highest density and—contrary to predictions—experienced their lowest nest predation rates; La Selva on the other hand experienced the lowest density and highest predation rate. Because nest predation decreased with fragmentation, it appears not to explain declines of understory insectivores from forest fragments generally. Nest survival models indicated that habitat best explained nest predation likelihood, whereas edge, annual, and nest age effects were unimportant. Video surveillance documented both bird-eating snake (Pseustes poecilonotus) causing 80% of nest loss overall (37 of 46 nests) and a larger variety of predators in fragments; thus, landscape factors influenced an understory bird’s nest predation. Given the large effect on our focal species, Pseustes likely affects other understory nesters, a topic warranting further study. Tropical reserve conservation plans should consider potential impacts of specialized nest predators on vulnerable understory birds.