Influence of crustal cumulates on 210Pb disequilibria in basalts

In historical basalts from a wide range of tectonic settings, 210Pb is often found to have an activity deficit relative to its predecessor 226Ra. Several processes have been hypothesized as causes of 210Pb deficits in basalts. In subduction zone and ocean island environments, 210Pb deficits have often been attributed to shallow magmatic degassing. At mid-ocean ridges, 210Pb deficits have been inferred to result from mantle melting, limiting the time between melt production and eruption to 100 years or less. Here we present an alternative mechanism for producing 210Pb deficits in magmas, by diffusive exchange between a melt and cumulate minerals (plagioclase and/or clinopyroxene) in the crust. The deficit in 210Pb develops in response to its decay toward secular equilibrium with 226Ra within the mineral grains; decay provides an internal sink for 210Pb that drives continuous diffusive exchange with the melt. Deficits in 210Pb develop under a broad range of conditions, in enriched and depleted melts and during interaction with young or old cumulate minerals. The magnitude of the deficit depends mainly on the equilibrium mineral/melt partition coefficients for Pb and Ra and on the melt/rock ratio during diffusive interaction, and is only weakly dependent on the relative diffusivities of Ra and Pb in the minerals or the trace element disequilibrium between the melt and cumulate minerals. Plagioclase in the crust has greater leverage on the 210Pb–226Ra system than any silicate mineral present during mantle melting, and is capable of inducing significant 210Pb deficits in the melt even at melt fractions above 50%. Its influence on the melt is also rapid, with a substantial 210Pb deficit developing in less than a year and approaching a steady state value after several decades or less. The strong control crustal cumulates are capable of exerting on 210Pb–226Ra fractionation in melts indicates that they may have a significant role in a wide range of tectonic environments, and suggests caution in interpreting 210Pb deficits as a signature of mantle melting, or as a product of 222Rn degassing.