A new method to estimate aquatic invertebrate diversity in French shallow lakes and ponds

- A method to monitor and predict invertebrate richness in French ponds and shallow lakes is proposed.
- The method is compared with several existing methods and other indicator groups.
- Comparison are based upon identification of all macroinvertebrates present in sites sampled.
- The new method, based on a holistic inventory at low taxonomic resolution is more effective than all other formulas.

Shallow lakes and ponds are valuable ecosystems for conservation management. Aquatic invertebrates constitute a large proportion of diversity in these ecosystems, but their assessment is potentially time consuming and requires great expertise. The use of indicator taxa to estimate invertebrate diversity may resolve part of these difficulties. These indicators are rarely identified or their reliability is uncertain, i.e. they are based on partial inventories, neglecting groups with high diversity. In this study, invertebrate richness was assessed from 46 sites in France in various altitudinal, climatic, geological, human-impacted, and hydro-morphological contexts. Invertebrate identification was performed as accurately as possible in all taxonomic groups. Several potential indicators of diversity based on five key criteria were tested: strong direct correlation, identification facilities, strong cross-taxon congruence, low complementarity of the sampled habitats, and ubiquity for selected indicators. Three approaches were proposed to define these indicator groups: (1) a single taxonomic group as indicator, (2) a combination of targeted groups, and (3) a holistic inventory at low taxonomic resolution as a classical rapid assessment method for freshwater ecosystems. Results show that it is not recommended to use only one indicator group. The choice of several targeted groups could be a good intermediate solution but is not without bias. The rapid assessment inventory proposed is the most valuable method, and allows the estimation of invertebrate richness with a quasi-perfect correlation.