Biological nitrogen fixation in three long-term organic and conventional arable crop rotation experiments in Denmark

Biological nitrogen (N) fixation (BNF) by legumes in organic cropping systems has been perceived as a strategy to substitute N import from conventional sources. However, the N contribution by legumes varies considerably depending on legumes species, as well as local soil and climatic conditions. There is a lack of knowledge on whether the N contribution of legumes estimated using short-term experiments reflects the long-term effects in organic systems varying in fertility building measures. There is also limited information on how fertilizer management practices in organic crop rotations affect BNF of legumes. Therefore, this study aimed to estimate BNF in long-term experiments with a range of organic and conventional arable crop rotations at three sites in Denmark varying in climate and soils (coarse sand, loamy sand and sandy loam) and to identify possible causes of differences in the amount of BNF. The experiment included 4-year crop rotations with three treatment factors in a factorial design: (i) rotations, i.e. organic with a year of grass-clover (OGC), organic with a year of grain legumes (OGL), and conventional with a year of grain legumes (CGL), (ii) with (+CC) and without (−CC) cover crops, and (iii) with (+M) and without (−M) animal manure in OGC and OGL, and with (+F) mineral fertilizer in CGL. Cover crops consisted of a mixture of perennial ryegrass and clover (at the sites with coarse sand and sandy loam soils) or winter rye, fodder radish and vetch (at the site with loamy sand soil) in OGC and OGL, and only perennial ryegrass in CGL at all sites. The BNF was measured using the N difference method. The proportion of N derived from the atmosphere (%Ndfa) in aboveground biomass of clover grown for an entire year in a mixture with perennial ryegrass and harvested three times during the growing season in OGC was close to 100% at all three sites. The Ndfa of grain legumes in both OGL and CGL rotations ranged between 61% and 95% depending on location with mostly no significant difference in Ndfa between treatments. Cover crops had more than 92% Ndfa at all sites. The total BNF per rotation cycle was higher in OGC than in OGL and CGL, mostly irrespective of manure/fertilizer or cover crop treatments. There was no significant difference in total BNF between OGL and CGL rotations, but large differences were observed between sites. The lowest cumulated BNF by all the legume species over the 4-year rotation cycle was obtained at the location with sandy loam soil, i.e. 224-244, 96-128, and 144-156 kg N ha−1 in OGC, OGL and CGL, respectively, whereas it was higher at the locations with coarse sand and loamy sand soil, i.e. 320-376, 168-264, and 200-220 kg N ha−1 in OGC, OGL and CGL, respectively. The study shows that legumes in organic crop rotations can maintain N2 fixation without being significantly affected by long-term fertilizer regimes or fertility building measures.