Phylogenetic relationships of the North American cyprinid subgenus Hydrophlox

Notropis is one of the largest genera of North American fishes and is composed of a number of morphologically diagnosed subgroups; however, the validity of many has not been tested in a phylogenetic framework. One such subgroup is the subgenus Hydrophlox, which is composed of brilliantly colored species that engage in the symbiotic reproductive behavior of nest association. Although they have long been recognized as a cohesive group due to their nuptial coloration and fin tuberculation, very little is known about the relationships of species within Hydrophlox. We tested the monophyly of Hydrophlox using a mitochondrial marker (ND2) and two nuclear markers (ITS1 and RH), with Maximum Parsimony and Bayesian inference approaches. A well supported clade of “core” Hydrophlox was recovered and is composed of five taxa: Notropis chiliticus, Notropis rubricroceus, Notropis lutipinnis, Notropis chlorocephalus, and Notropis chrosomus. Hydrophlox s.l. is paraphyletic with respect to three taxa: Notropis baileyi, Notropis leuciodus and Notropis nubilus. While there was some discordance among the individual marker topologies, a combined evidence analysis recovered a topology that incorporated elements from all single-gene trees. Our analyses suggest that Hydrophlox is composed of five nominal species and additional undescribed diversity exists within this clade.

Highlights► The Notropis subgenus Hydrophlox s.l. (Euteleostei: Cyprinidae) is not monophyletic. ► Hydrophlox includes: Notropis rubricroceus, N. chiliticus, N. chlorocephalus, N. lutipinnis, and N. chrosomus. ► Subgenus Hydrophlox is sister to the Notropis texanus species group. ► Hydrophlox contains at least three undescribed species.