Fractional standard map: Riemann–Liouville vs. Caputo

Properties of the phase space of the standard maps with memory obtained from the differential equations with the Riemann–Liouville and Caputo derivatives are considered. Properties of the attractors which these fractional dynamical systems demonstrate are different from properties of the regular and chaotic attractors of systems without memory: they exist in the asymptotic sense, different types of trajectories may lead to the same attracting points, trajectories may intersect, and chaotic attractors may overlap. Two maps have significant differences in the types of attractors they demonstrate and convergence of trajectories to the attracting points and trajectories. Still existence of the most remarkable new type of attractors, “cascade of bifurcation type trajectories”, is a common feature of both maps.

Research highlights
► In fractional maps trajectories may intersect and attractors may overlap.
► Fractional maps demonstrate “cascade of bifurcation type attractors”.
► Caputo and Reimann–Liouville maps may demonstrate different types of attractors.