Reliability of upper limb and trunk joint angles in healthy adults during activities of daily living

Assessments of upper limb performance should require participants to perform tasks that challenge the limits of their ability. In order to select appropriate tasks, it is important to know which joints are used to perform the movement and how reliably those movements can be measured. The purpose of this work was to quantify the reliability of upper limb and trunk joint angles in healthy adults during common activities of daily living (ADLs). Nineteen participants performed six ADLs with the right arm (applying deodorant, turning a doorknob, answering a desk telephone, placing a pushpin in a bulletin board, wiping a plate with a towel, and pouring water from a pitcher) during two separate sessions. Within- and between-session reliability was quantified using intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs) and minimum detectable change values (MDCs). Reliability was generally better within-session than between-session. The ICCs exceeded 0.75 for 88% of the joint angles and exceeded 0.90 for 32% of the angles. All MDCs were less than 25° and 61% were also less than 10°. The MDCs represented a larger percent of the average angles for the trunk (61%) and wrist (62%) compared to the shoulder (18%) and elbow (26%). Although these results show that most angles can be measured reliably for these six ADLs, reliability varied considerably between joints. It is therefore important to select tasks for assessing of upper limb performance based on which specific joints need to be evaluated.