Predicting counterproductive work behaviors with sub-clinical psychopathy: Beyond the Five Factor Model of personality

• Agreeableness and conscientiousness correlate with counterproductive behavior.
• Sub-clinical psychopathy correlates with counterproductive behavior.
• Agreeableness and conscientiousness explain variance in counterproductive behavior.
• Agreeableness explains variance in interpersonal deviance.
• Sub-clinical psychopathy explains the most variance in counterproductive behavior.

Organizational psychologists examining personality’s relation to work behavior have focused largely on the “normal” traits comprising the Five Factor Model (FFM). However, given the aversive nature of sub-clinical psychopathy (e.g., callous affect, impulsivity), we posit that this toxic personality profile will enhance the prediction of negative work outcomes, namely forms of counterproductive workplace behavior (CWB). Study 1 (N = 193) examined the value of sub-clinical psychopathy and the FFM in predicting intentions to engage in CWB; results support prior research indicating that both agreeableness and conscientiousness significantly correlated with CWB. In addition, sub-clinical psychopathy predicted CWB above and beyond the FFM. Study 2 (N = 360) extended the findings of Study 1 by examining interpersonally deviant behavior in a team context. While agreeableness was significantly related to interpersonal deviance in Study 2, conscientiousness was not. Results from Study 2 replicate Study 1, suggesting that sub-clinical psychopathy accounted for the majority of the explained variance in interpersonal deviance. Overall, the results support the value of using sub-clinical psychopathy to predict CWB.