Testing for defensive synergy in Caribbean sponges: Bad taste or glass spicules?

Chemical and physical defenses of sessile organisms against consumers are well described for both terrestrial and marine systems. However, previous studies have focused on chemical or physical defenses in isolation, and have not considered their interaction. Marine sponges provide a model system for testing this interaction. Some sponge species produce secondary metabolites that deter predation; they may also contain siliceous spicules, but previous studies have provided little evidence that spicules in isolation offer any defense against generalist fish predators. To determine whether the two components have an additive, antagonistic, or synergistic interaction, crude organic extracts and spicules from individuals of 8 Caribbean sponge species were isolated and tested in laboratory feeding assays. These included one chemically defended reef sponge (Agelas clathrodes) and seven known to be intermediately deterrent: six from reef habitats (Cinachyrella alloclada, Clathria virgultosa, Cribrochalina infundibulum, Niphates digitalis, Svenzea zeai, and Xestospongia muta) and one from mangrove habitats (Tedania ignis). Extracts and spicules were assayed at various concentrations, both individually and in combination, in laboratory feeding assays with the bluehead wrasse, Thalassoma bifasciatum. A SAS based GENMOD procedure based on an isobolographic analysis model was used for statistical comparisons. Four sponges (A. clathrodes, C. alloclada, C. virgultosa, and one of three individuals of X. muta) showed evidence of synergisms. Of these, synergy in C. alloclada, C. virgultosa, and X. muta was caused by approximately natural concentrations of extracts and spicules. The extract of A. clathrodes was deterrent, but combination assays required nearly a 3-fold reduction in extract concentration and an 8-fold increase in spicule concentration to show the synergistic effect. Contrary to previous findings, spicules from C. infundibulum and two of three individuals of X. muta were deterrent at natural concentrations. Sponge spicules may be defensive in isolation, or may enhance chemical defenses against consumers, but the lack of synergisms for individuals in 4 of 7 species with intermediate levels of chemical defense suggests that defensive synergy is not the general rule and, when present, may be an example of an exaptation.