Centers of control: Revealing elites among the Ancestral Pueblo during the “Chaco Phenomenon”

The use of violence as a means of social control among higher status members of the Ancestral Pueblo is explored by using data derived from the burials and the burial context of several sites between AD 850 and 1300. High-status burials, while relatively rare in the archeological record, are of interest because of the role the individuals are assumed to have played in the culture. It has been suggested that there were “elites” among the Ancestral Pueblo during a particularly volatile period that corresponds with the growth, development, and decline of Chacon Canyon and to a lesser extent Aztec Ruins, two major political and ritual centers. Using a bioarchaeological approach that integrates the human remains with the archeological context, burials from Chaco Canyon were compared with burials from other sites in the region based on demographic (age and sex), nutritional (stature), activity (robusticity and entheses), health (pathological conditions), violence (cranial trauma), and cultural (mortuary pattern) patterns. Crucial for expanding our understanding of the role of hierarchy and social control in the Pueblo world, these data suggest that there were high-status individuals who functioned as political and ceremonial leaders.

► Examines the role of violence as a mechanism of social control among elites.
► Analyzes social inequality by looking at trauma, activity-related changes, and pathological conditions.
► Findings suggests that there were “elites” at the height of the “Chaco Phenomenon”.
► While violence was reduced compared with the periods before and after Chaco, it was still present.
► Concludes that although there were high-status individuals, the extent of their control was limited.