Correlated selection responses for female fertility after selection for high protein yield or low mastitis frequency in Norwegian Red cows

Correlated selection responses in female fertility were estimated from a selection experiment with 2 groups of Norwegian Red cows selected for high protein yield (HPY) and low mastitis frequency (LCM), respectively. Genetic trends were calculated for nonreturn rate within 56 d after first insemination (NR56) for heifers, first-lactation cows, and second- and third-lactation cows, calving interval between first and second calving (CIN), and interval from calving to first insemination (CFI) for first-lactation cows and for second- and third-lactation cows. A total of 5,001 cows from the selection experiment had estimated breeding values for fertility, of which 2,806 were HPY and 2,195 were LCM cows. Permutation tests showed significant genetic differences between LCM and HPY for all fertility traits except CFI for second- and third-lactation cows. Observed differences between mean EBV in HPY and in LCM were, with few exceptions, far outside the range of the permutation test (i.e., significantly different from zero). LCM cows were, in general, genetically more fertile than HPY cows, with higher NR56 in heifers and cows, shorter CIN, and shorter CFI in first lactation. Genetic differences between HPY and LCM after 6 cow-generations were 2.5 percentage units NR56 in heifers, 2 percentage units NR56 in cows, and 4 d for CIN. No difference was found for CFI in second and third lactation. This is the first report of genetic change in female fertility as a correlated response after selection against mastitis.