Diet fermentability influences lactational performance responses to corn distillers grains: A meta-analysis

Increasing supply of corn distillers grains (CDG) raises questions about the extent to which they can be used in diets of lactating dairy cows. A database of treatment means (n = 44) reported in 16 peer-reviewed journal articles published from 1985 to 2008 was developed. The database included response (within study) to a CDG diet compared with the control (no CDG) for milk yield (MY), milk fat concentration and yield, CDG content of the diet, and dietary composition of control and CDG diets (% of dietary dry matter). Additionally, corn grain fermentability was classified as high moisture (n = 7) or dry (n = 37). Data from studies with diets including more than one grain source (n = 8) had been eliminated from the analysis. Dietary concentrations of CDG ranged from 4.2 to 42% across studies. Dietary concentrations in diets containing CDG were 16.8 ± 1.91% (mean ± standard deviation) crude protein, 36 ± 15.5% corn silage, 23 ± 8.8% corn grain, and 28 ± 5.8% starch. Responses to CDG were 0.5 ± 2.10 kg/cow per day (mean ± standard deviation) for MY, 0.05 ± 0.178 percentage units for milk fat concentration, and 26 ± 77.6 g/cow per day for milk fat yield. Only MY response was related to increasing concentrations of CDG in diets and peaked at 1.2 kg/cow per day for 21% CDG. Diet fermentability was associated with responses. The greatest MY response to CDG was with 24% corn silage or 23% starch, and concentrations greater than 47% corn silage or 32% starch resulted in negative MY responses. Responses in MY differed by level of MY and were often more evident in higher- (>30.0 kg MY/d) than in lower-producing cows. Milk fat concentration response was not related to dietary CDG, but was correlated linearly with milk fat concentration of cows fed the control diet. Milk fat concentration greater than 3.6% for the control treatment was related to a negative milk fat concentration response to CDG, regardless of dietary concentration of CDG. Partially replacing high-moisture corn with CDG increased milk fat concentration by 0.16 percentage units compared with that from dry corn. When formulating diets with CDG, diet fermentability and level of MY (higher vs. lower) must be considered. Concentrations of corn silage and starch must be moderate to optimize lactational responses to CDG. Overall, lactational response to CDG in this database was dependent on diet fermentability and milk fat concentration in the control.