Kepler: Analogies in the search for the law of refraction

• We show that Kepler used a Pythagorean methodology to discover a law of refraction.
• We show why the Kepler's analogies failed.
• We clarify the heuristics that led finally to the Kepler's law of refraction.

This paper examines the methodology used by Kepler to discover a quantitative law of refraction. The aim is to argue that this methodology follows a heuristic method based on the following two Pythagorean principles: (1) sameness is made known by sameness, and (2) harmony arises from establishing a limit to what is unlimited. We will analyse some of the author's proposed analogies to find the aforementioned law and argue that the investigation's heuristic pursues such principles.