Trivalent chromium and aluminum affect the thermostability and conformation of collagen very differently

Ultrasensitive differential scanning calorimetry (US-DSC) was used to directly measure the thermal transition temperature and energy change of acid soluble collagen in the presence of Cr3 + and Al3 + sulfates. The behavior of Cr3 + was analogous to kosmotropes in the cation Hofmeister series and increased the stability of collagen in dilute solutions. Meanwhile, the denaturational enthalpy change (ΔH) of collagen was substantially reduced with change to increasing Cr3 + concentration. This is likely due to the uni-point binding of Cr3 + with carboxyl groups of collagen side chains that could decrease the hydrogen-bonding in collagen and result in the increase of protein hydrophobicity. In the case of Al3 +, the interactions between the ions and collagen showed very different properties: at low and medium ion concentrations, the stability of the collagen was decreased; however, a further increase of Al3 + concentration led to a salting-out effect of collagen, indicating the Al3 + is a typical chaotropic ion. This striking difference of the two ions in the stabilization of collagen can be explained in terms of the different interactions between the cations and the carboxyl groups of collagen side chains. Additionally, we studied metal ion induced conformational change by the combination of circular dichroism (CD) and atomic force microscopy (AFM). CD measurements revealed that neither metal ion interactions of collagen with Cr3 + nor Al3 + ions destroyed the triple-helical backbone structure of collagen in the solution. AFM results further confirmed that the dehydration of collagen by Cr3 + is more significant than Al3 +, thus inducing the aggregation of collagen fibrils.

US-DSC thermograms showed significantly different effects of Cr3 + and Al3 + on acid soluble collagen (ΔH, Tm, Cp). These differences can be explained by specific ion effect following the concept of matching water affinities. Neither Cr3 + nor Al3 + destroyed the collagen triple helix but induced different molecular aggregation morphologies.Figure optionsDownload as PowerPoint slideHighlights
► Cr3 + increased collagen thermostability but decreased its denaturational enthalpy.
► Al3 + decreased collagen stability at low and medium ion concentrations.
► The behavior of Cr3 + was analogous to kosmotropes, whereas Al3 + was chaotropic.
► Neither Cr3 + nor Al3 + destroyed the triple helix conformation of collagen.
► Cr3 + and Al3 + induced different morphological changes of collagen.