Mechanistic Comparison of “Nearly Missed” Versus “On-Target” Rotor Ablation

ObjectivesThis study used advanced optical mapping techniques to examine atrial fibrillation (AF) dynamics before and after 2 distinct electrogram-based ablation strategies: complex fractionated atrial electrograms (CFAEs) and DFmax/rotor ablation.BackgroundAmong the electrogram analytical features proposed to unravel the atrial regions that perpetuate AF, CFAEs, highest dominant frequency sites (DFmax), and, more recently, phase analysis-enabled rotor mapping have received the largest attention. Still, the mechanisms by which these approaches modulate AF dynamics and lead to AF termination are unknown.MethodsIn Langendorff-perfused sheep hearts, AF was maintained by the continuous perfusion of acetylcholine and high-resolution endocardial-epicardial optical videos were recorded from the left atrial free wall and the posterior left atrium. Then, DFmax/rotor regions (n = 7), or CFAE regions harboring the highest wavebreak density (HWD) (n = 5), were targeted with a 4F ablation catheter (5 to 15 W, 30 to 60 s/point). Thereafter, we examined the changes in AF dynamics and whether AF terminated.ResultsDFmax/rotor point ablation resulted in a significant decrease in DFmax values. In 2 animals AF terminated, whereas in the remaining 5 animals the post-ablation DFmax domain remained in the vicinity of its pre-ablation location. However, after HWD/CFAEs density ablation, DFmax values did not change, AF did not terminate, and post-ablation DFmax domains relocated from the left atrial free wall to the pulmonary vein–posterior left atrium region. In another group of hearts (n = 12), we observed that upon a progressive increase in acetylcholine concentration—mimicking the acute electrophysiological changes occurring after ablation—3-dimensional rotors drifted from one atrial region to another along large gradients of myocardial thickness.Conclusions“On-target” DFmax/rotor ablation leads to the annihilation of the fibrillation-driving rotor. This translates into large decreases in AF frequency or AF termination. In contrast, “nearly missed” HWD/CFAEs ablation spares the fibrillation-driving rotor, and set the stage for rotor drift along large myocardial thickness gradients.