Crop cultivation and intensive grazing affect organic C pools and aggregate stability in arid grassland soil

The effects of cultivation and overgrazing on soil quality in arid regions have been rarely addressed. This study investigated the roles of cropping and grazing in soil organic C pools and aggregate stability at 0–20 cm depth by comparing conventional grazing (non-fenced ever), intensive grazing (fenced for 22 years) and cropping (cultivated for 40 years) in the arid Hexi Corridor of northwestern China. Total soil organic C (TOC) under non-fenced grazing was 21.6 g kg−1 (or 52.9 Mg ha−1), which was 19.9% (or 13.2% mass per area) lower than that under fenced grazing, because of lower stable organic C fraction (<0.05 mm) (i.e., 15.2 g kg−1 or 37.4 Mg ha−1 in non-fenced versus 19.2 g kg−1 or 44.5 Mg ha−1 in fenced grazing). Cropping had similar TOC concentration but 15.7% less TOC mass per area compared with non-fenced grazing mainly due to a decrease in coarse organic C (2–0.1 mm) (i.e., 4.1 g kg−1 or 10.1 Mg ha−1 in non-fenced versus 2.9 g kg−1 or 6.0 Mg ha−1 in cropping). Non-fenced grazing produced 1.49, 1.17 and 0.19 g kg−1 of soil carbohydrate C extracted by concentrated acid, diluted acid and hot water, respectively. The three carbohydrate C fractions were increased by 21.5, 14.5 and 15.8% under fenced grazing but lowered by 12.8, 18.8 and 21.1% under cropping, respectively. Soil mineralized C after 51-day incubation was the highest under fenced grazing followed by non-fenced grazing, and the lowest under cropping. Percentage of water-stable aggregates (>0.25 mm) in total aggregates and mean weight diameter were 15% and 0.28 mm under cropping, significantly lower than 65% and 3.11 mm under non-fenced grazing and 65% and 2.84 mm under fenced grazing. The aggregates of >1 mm were almost entirely demolished under cropping when subjected to wet sieving. Reduction of soil carbohydrates under cropping was closely related to the decline in aggregate water-stability. The negative effects of cropping on soil organic C pool and aggregate water-stability may suggest that cropping on this arid grassland is not sustainable unless no-tillage is adopted. In favor of increasing soil carbohydrates and maintaining soil aggregation, fenced-grazing would be a better option than cropping and non-fenced grazing for the management of arid grasslands.