HSV IgG antibody inhibits virus detection in CSF

BackgroundBefore PCR testing of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF), laboratory diagnosis of herpes encephalitis (HSE) was based on virus isolation from brain biopsy. Viral isolation from CSF has limited clinical value due to low virus recovery; the cause for which has not been demonstrated.ObjectiveTo investigate the role of anti-HSV antibodies on recovery of HSV from CSF via cell culture.Study designHSV-positive CSF samples were evaluated for their ability to neutralize HSV in cell culture. The presence of HSV-specific IgG and IgM antibodies were analyzed using HSV-infected cells. To identify whether HSV-specific IgG is the cause of viral inhibition, IgG was removed using anti-human IgG magnetic beads. Viral inhibition from CSF originating from asymptomatic patients was examined as a comparison.ResultsCSF from 13 patients with acute HSV CNS disease was analyzed. All displayed high levels of viral neutralization to both HSV-1 and HSV-2 regardless of the infecting subtype. Interestingly, all the CSF samples stained strongly for anti-IgG antibody but none for anti-IgM antibody. Removal of IgG from CSF eliminated the viral inhibitory activity. Neutralizing IgG antibody was also found to be common in CSF of most patients, even in the absence of HSV disease.ConclusionsViral specific IgG is the major determinant of viral inhibition in CSF and prevents virus recovery in cell culture. In CSF from HSE un-infected patients, viral inhibitory IgG originates from circulating serum antibody and is commonly present in CSF. However, this inhibitory IgG is not protective for the development of HSV disease.