Preferential predatory peeling: Ammonoid vs. nautiloid shells from the Upper Carboniferous of Texas, USA

Narrow groove-like excavations on ammonoid and coiled nautiloid shells are rare in Upper Carboniferous units from Texas, USA. The morphological characteristics of the excavation grooves typically are confined to the ventral and ventrolateral parts of the outer whorl of the shell, are narrower than the length, and have irregular edges where small segments or chips of shells have been removed. Analysis of these features reveals a statistically significant preferential occurrence on ammonoids (1.195% of ca. 3515 specimens) as compared to coiled nautiloids (0.506% of ca. 2965 specimens). The ammonoids typically have longer excavations that penetrate the phragmocone more frequently than those observed in the coiled nautiloids. The groove-like excavations were probably formed by the removal and peeling of shell material by one or more predatory or scavenging arthropods to obtain organic material (tissue and membranes) within the ammonoid and nautiloid body chambers and phragmocones. The excavations probably occurred when the cephalopod was alive (i.e., the cause of death) or shortly after the cephalopod's death. There is no evidence that the excavations are related to sheltering by the excavating organism.