Impact of hardwood species on production cost of second generation ethanol

The present work targeted the understanding of the influence of nine different hardwood species as feedstock on ethanol production yield and costs. It was found that the minimum ethanol revenue (MER) ($ per gallon to the producer) to achieve a 12% internal rate of return (IRR) on invested capital was smaller for low lignin content samples and the influence of species characteristics remained restricted to high residual lignin content. We show that if the pretreatment being applied to the feedstock targets or is limited to low lignin removal, one can expect the species to have a significant impact on overall economics, playing important role to project success. This study also showed a variation of up to 40% in relative MER among hardwood species, where maple, globulus and sweet gum varied the least. Sensitivity analysis showed ethanol yield per ton of feedstock had the largest influence in MER, followed by CAPEX.

Figure optionsDownload as PowerPoint slideHighlights
► Study targeted the influence of different hardwood species on ethanol production yield and costs.
► Minimum ethanol revenue was lower for extended kraft-pretreated samples.
► The influence of species characteristics remained restricted to high residual lignin content.
► Species such as maple, globulus and sweet gum presented the lowest variation in relative MER.
► Sensitivity analysis showed that ethanol yield has the largest influence in MER followed by CAPEX.