Benefits and limitations to straw- and plastic-film mulch on maize yield and water use efficiency: A meta-analysis across hydrothermal gradients

Ridge-furrow mulching can reduce soil evaporation and conserve rainfall, thereby increasing crop yield and water use efficiency (WUE) in dryland cropping systems. In this study, we collected 837 observations from 50 published papers and used meta-analysis to investigate whether ridge-furrow and mulching practices are equally effective on maize yield, WUE and evapotranspiration (ET) across a range of precipitation and temperature gradients and soil types in China. Five practices were included: (i) straw mulch on flat plots (SMF), (ii) straw mulch on ridge-furrow plots (SMR), (iii) plastic mulch on flat plots (PMF), (iv) plastic mulch on ridge-furrow plots (PMR), and (v) flat plots without mulch, which was used as a control (CK). The meta-analysis showed that both straw mulch and plastic mulch significantly increased maize yields and WUE (except for SMR), and that plastic mulch was more effective than straw mulch in increasing yields, particularly in cold and dry environments. PMR has the highest yields and is more effective in clay loam than in silt loam soils. Straw mulch, but particularly plastic mulch, increased the soil moisture compared to the CK, while plastic mulch increased soil temperature, mainly in spring. However, the positive effect of plastic mulch on maize yield diminished with increasing mean growing-season temperature and precipitation, reaching zero (similar to the CK of no mulch and flat plots) when the growing-season precipitation was greater than 770 mm and the mean growing-season air temperature exceeded 24 °C. The small benefit of straw mulch (on average about 12%) was similar across the precipitation and temperature gradients, including when the benefits of plastic mulch reached zero. While our analysis has shown the benefits of ridge-furrow plastic mulch on yield and water-use efficiency, it has also highlighted the limitations of the benefits. The results provide a guide to the regions where plastic-film mulch and ridge-furrow planting are likely to improve maize yields and regions where the benefits are likely to be limited.