Readability and comprehension of self-report binge eating measures

The validity of self-report binge eating instruments among individuals with limited literacy is uncertain. This study aims to evaluate reading grade level and multiple domains of comprehension of 13 commonly used self-report assessments of binge eating for use in low-literacy populations. We evaluated self-report binge eating measures with respect to reading grade levels, measure length, formatting and linguistic problems.ResultsAll measures were written at a reading grade level higher than is recommended for patient materials (above the 5th to 6th grade level), and contained several challenging elements related to comprehension. Correlational analyses suggested that readability and comprehension elements were distinct contributors to measure difficulty. Individuals with binge eating who have low levels of educational attainment or limited literacy are often underrepresented in measure validation studies. Validity of measures and accurate assessment of symptoms depend on an individual's ability to read and comprehend instructions and items, and these may be compromised in populations with lower levels of literacy.

► We evaluated reading and comprehension levels of self-report binge eating measures.
► All measures exceeded reading level recommendations and had linguistic problems.
► Reading level and comprehension measure distinct aspects of measure difficulty.
► Accurate assessment of binge eating in low literacy populations may be compromised.
► Measure development should include the evaluation of readability and comprehension.