Synthesis and initial in vitro biological evaluation of two new zinc-chelating compounds: Comparison with TPEN and PAC-1

The lipophilic, cell-penetrating zinc chelator N,N,N′,N′,-tetrakis(2-pyridylmethyl) ethylenediamine (TPEN, 1) and the zinc chelating procaspase-activating compound PAC-1 (2) both have been reported to induce apoptosis in various cell types. The relationship between apoptosis-inducing ability and zinc affinity (Kd), have been investigated with two new model compounds, ZnA-DPA (3) and ZnA-Pyr (4), and compared to that of TPEN and PAC-1. The zinc-chelating o-hydroxybenzylidene moiety in PAC-1 was replaced with a 2,2′-dipicoylamine (DPA) unit (ZnA-DPA, 3) and a 4-pyridoxyl unit (ZnA-Pyr, 4), rendering an order of zinc affinity TPEN > ZnA-Pyr > ZnA-DPA > PAC-1. The compounds were incubated with the rat pheochromocytoma cell line PC12 and cell death was measured in combination with ZnSO4, a caspase-3 inhibitor, or a ROS scavenger. The model compounds ZnA-DPA (3) and ZnA-Pyr (4) induced cell death at higher concentrations as compared to PAC-1 and TPEN, reflecting differences in lipophilicity and thereby cell-penetrating ability. Addition of ZnSO4 reduced cell death induced by ZnA-Pyr (4) more than for ZnA-DPA (3). The ability to induce cell death could be reversed for all compounds using a caspase-3-inhibitor, and most so for TPEN (1) and ZnA-Pyr (4). Reactive oxygen species (ROS), as monitored using dihydro-rhodamine (DHR), were involved in cell death induced by all compounds. These results indicate that the Zn-chelators ZnA-DPA (3) and ZnA-Pyr (4) exercise their apoptosis-inducing effect by mechanisms similar to TPEN (1) and PAC-1 (2), by chelation of zinc, caspase-3 activation, and ROS production.