Supramolecular aromaticity

• Crystallographic samples of RAHBs from CSD are aromatic at supramolecular level.
• Stability of quasirings is increased as their supramolecular aromaticity increases.
• SAI is an efficient tool to monitor changes in aromaticity during chemical reactions.
• Supramolecular aromaticity involves much less mobile π-electron than usual aromaticity.
• Supramolecular aromaticity occurs with the aid of σ-delocalization.

We report experimental and theoretical evidences for supramolecular aromaticity as a new concept to be widely used in researches about molecular crystals. CSD survey regarding frequently encountered resonance-assisted H-bonds (RAHBs) in formic acid, formamide, formimidamide, formic acid–formamide, and formamide–formimidamide dimers shows that supramolecular quasirings formed by RAHBs have remarkable electronic delocalization within themselves, which is reminiscent of aromaticity at supramolecular level. This study criticizes and reevaluates the validity of conventional judgment which states that ring systems formed by intermolecular H-bonds cannot be aromatic. Thus, the term aromaticity can be extended to supramolecular systems formed by RAHBs. Supramolecular aromaticity has a multi-fold nature involving both σ- and π-delocalization, and σ-delocalization through RAHBs takes on a task of compensating σ-deficiency within quasirings. Atomic composition in donor–acceptor set of the dimers is descriptive for supramolecular aromaticity. We revised bond-valence parameters for RAHBs and they suggest that hypervalent character of H atoms is more pronounced than their hypovalent character in RAHBs. The σ-delocalized bonding within H-bonded quasirings necessitates hypervalent character of H atoms. Quantum chemical calculations based on adiabatic Hydrogen Atom Transfer (HAT) between the monomers reveal that topological parameters at ring critical points (RCPs) of the quasirings correlate well with Shannon’s entropic aromaticity index. The presence of additional LP orbital on O atoms implying more diffused LP-orbitals in donor–acceptor set leads to the formation of resonance-disabling states reducing supramolecular aromaticity of a quasiring and energetic cost of the electron transfer between the monomers. There is a nonignorable electron transfer between the monomers even in the cases where H atoms are close to donor or acceptor atom. NBO analyses have revealed that formally vacant LP* orbitals on H-atoms in TS geometries mediate intermolecular electron transfer as a result of the hyperconjugative stereoelectronic interactions.

Figure optionsDownload as PowerPoint slide