Solids flux measurements via alternate techniques in a gas-fluidized bed

A transportable fluidization column, operating under identical conditions at three different locations, was employed to compare three experimental solids flux measurement techniques for hydrodynamic characterization of gas-fluidized beds. This paper compares measurements of solids mass and momentum flux obtained by radioactive particle tracking at the Ecole Polytechnique, positron emission particle tracking at University of Birmingham, and borescopic high speed particle image velocimetry at PSRI, carried out with FCC particles of mean diameter 107 μm. These techniques provided broadly similar time-average solids flux profiles, but there were significant quantitative differences. Analysis of the results, focusing on the fundamentals of each measurement technique, provides valuable insights into the reasons for the discrepancies. The results also add to a unique hydrodynamic database for validation of CFD and other models.