Coastal issues and conflicts in North West Europe: A comparative analysis

This paper identifies and examines current coastal issues and conflicts in the northwest Europe region through the use of questionnaire surveys. The overall management concerns and outstanding problems across the region are highlighted and the results are presented in relation to previously identified management issues in northeast England, east Grampian in Scotland, and France. The survey presents a list of identified issues, each of which has a direct relationship to one of the 3 pillars of sustainable development, (environment, economic and social), and therefore the Lisbon Agenda (economic and social) and the Gothenburg Agenda (environment and environmental risk). The survey reveals that the important coastal management issues across the region are the large-scale concerns traditionally associated with ICZM: land-use planning, estuary management, natural resource and landscape protection, and water quality. Generally, respondents considered that management response to these issues is poor. Dissatisfaction levels were particularly high in France and Ireland, and to a lesser extent, in England. Water quality management escapes general criticism. This can be regarded as a positive finding, because it indicates that pan-European initiatives (the water-related EU directives) can deal effectively with this pan-European problem. The paper considers the links between the main issues across North West Europe and aims to distinguish how current coastal management practices have affected the range of issues arising.

Research highlights
► General satisfaction with management of land-use planning across NW Europe (NWE) except in NI.
► The satisfaction with planning indicates coastal development is not a concern across most of NWE.
► Movement of spotlight away from environmental issues and sustainable development.
► Poor management of ICZM administrative and procedural issues e.g. inter-governmental cooperation.
► Management of water quality is perceived as good indicating EU legislative initiatives can work.