Multi-criteria analysis as a tool for sustainability assessment of a waste management model

• We develop a model to assess sustainability of waste management scenario with energy recovery.
• The methodology we develop is based on the analytic hierarchy process.
• We examined the influence of the number of indicators in scenarios ranking.
• We introduce a new criterion for selection of indicators for waste treatment with energy recovery.
• The best sustainable scenario is recycling inorganic and composting organic waste.

To assess the sustainability of waste management scenario with energy recovery, it is necessary to carry out an adequate analysis of all influential criteria. The main problem in the analysis is to determine the indicators that clearly and fully sublimate the most important influential factors. The model for the assessment of the sustainability of waste treatment scenarios based on multi-criteria analysis AHP (analytic hierarchy process) method is developed. The model predicts an increase in the number of indicators, if it found that a selected number of indicators are not sufficient to distinguish between scenarios and new criterion for the selection of indicators: the relevance of the indicator for certain waste treatment. The model is verified in the case study the city of Niš. Four scenarios were selected and examined: business as usual scenario (landfilling of waste) and the other are created as scenarios with energy recovery and recourses preserving: composting organic waste with recycling inorganic waste, incineration of waste and anaerobic digestion of waste. The assessment of the sustainability of waste treatment scenarios was made in several steps. It is found that the best sustainable scenario is composting of organic and recycling of inorganic waste.