Chemical differences of aquatic humic substances extracted by XAD-8 and DEAE-cellulose

Chemical characteristics of dissolved organic matter (DOM) extracted from an ombrotrophic bog in northern Minnesota by two methods – XAD-8 and DEAE-cellulose – were compared using 13C NMR spectroscopy, excitation–emission matrix fluorescence spectroscopy (EEMS), and Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry (FT-ICR MS). DOM extracted with XAD-8, a relatively hydrophobic sorbent, had a larger 13C NMR signal in the aromatic carbon region, but DOM extracted by DEAE-cellulose, a weak anion exchanger, had a larger signal in the carboxylic carbon region. DOM extracts prepared by the two methods were similar in their overall chemical characteristics that serve as proxies for organic matter sources. For example, only small differences were observed in the fluorescence index (FI) values of the extracts, and all values were within the range expected for terrestrially-derived DOM. EEMS spectra of both extracts had “humic-like” peak A areas smaller than that of standard reference Suwannee River fulvic acid. Of 2801 distinct chemical formulas assigned during FT-ICR MS analysis of the two extracts, 66% were present in both; 15% were unique to the XAD-8 extract, and 19% were unique to the DEAE-cellulose extract. Van Krevelen plots showed that the DEAE-cellulose extract had more tannin-like and condensed aromatic entities and formulas with higher O/C ratios, whereas the XAD-8 extract had more lignin-like material and formulas with higher H/C ratios. Overall, differences in chemical characteristics of the extracts reflect the mechanisms by which the extractants operate.