Screening risk assessment tools for assessing the environmental impact in an abandoned pyritic mine in Spain

This paper describes a new methodology for assessing site-specific environmental impact of contaminants. The proposed method integrates traditional risk assessment approaches with real and variable environmental characteristics at a local scale. Environmental impact on selected receptors was classified for each environmental compartment into 5 categories derived from the whole (chronic and acute) risk assessment using 8 risk levels. Risk levels were established according to three hazard quotients (HQs) which represented the ratio of exposure to acute and chronic toxicity values. This tool allowed integrating in only one impact category all the elements involved in the standard risk assessment.The methodology was applied to an abandoned metal mine in Spain, where high levels of As, Cd, Zn and Cu were detected. Risk affecting potential receptors such as aquatic and soil organisms and terrestrial vertebrates were assessed. Whole results showed that impact to the ecosystem is likely high and further investigation or remedial actions are necessary. Some proposals to refine the risk assessment for a more realistic diagnostic are included.

Research Highlights
► New procedure for assessing site-specific environmental impacts in contaminated sites.
► Classification of environmental impacts based on acute and chronic hazard quotients.
► The method focuses on aquatic and terrestrial receptors using risk assessment tools.
► Application of novel methodology to an abandoned pyritic mine in Spain.
► As and metals in the site may affect all potentially receptors excepting livestock.