Clearfield® rice: Its development, success, and key challenges on a global perspective

• Herbicide-resistant (Clearfield®) rice was developed to control weedy rice in rice.
• The majority of rice cultivars planted in the southern US are Clearfield® inbred or hybrid.
• Clearfield® rice quickly gained foothold in Central and South America; now also in Europe and Asia.
• Sustainability hinges on management of gene flow, seed systems, and other challenges.

Weedy rice (Oryza sativa) is a close relative of domesticated rice and a noxious weed prevalent in rice fields in world regions where rice is grown. Weedy rice management has remained challenging to farmers, mainly due to the weed's physiological and morphological resemblance to rice cultivars. The introduction of Clearfield® rice provides an alternative solution and an additional tool for integrated weed management. Clearfield® rice-based programs result in the cleanest rice fields in the southern U.S. However, persistent application of the imidazolinone herbicides (imazethapyr, imazamox, and imazapic) in Clearfield® rice raises concerns about the possible evolution of resistance to ALS-inhibitor herbicides in weedy rice and the transfer of resistance trait. The risk of resistant weedy rice evolution is much higher in Asia, Latin America, and other tropical regions where there is no winterkill and rice is planted at least twice each year. Herbicide carryover to rotational crops is also a concern. We summarized the progress of commercialization of Clearfield® rice in 15 countries across the continents of America, Asia and Europe. In some countries, imidazolinone-resistant weedy rice outcrosses have been found abundant, thereby negating the utility of Clearfield® technology. The persistence of imidazolinone herbicide residues in the soil is a concern in regions where multiple crops are planted in a year, or the following year. These challenges should be anticipated by countries that are considering adopting Clearfield® rice technology. Issues associated with gene escape, resistance evolution in weedy rice, and herbicide carryover to rotational crops remain to be resolved. Research to achieve sustainable solutions for weedy rice management, must be continued and intense educational programs for growers must be sustained.