Safety assessment of boron by application of new uncertainty factors and their subdivision

The available toxicity information for boron was reevaluated and four appropriate toxicity studies were selected in order to derive a tolerable daily intake (TDI) using newly proposed uncertainty factors (UFs) presented in Hasegawa et al. (2010). No observed adverse effect levels (NOAELs) of 17.5 and 8.8 mg B/kg/day for the critical effect of testicular toxicity were found in 2-year rat and dog feeding studies. Also, the 95% lower confidence limit of the benchmark doses for 5% reduction of fetal body weight (BMDL05) was calculated as 44.9 and 10.3 mg B/kg/day in mouse and rat developmental toxicity studies, respectively. Measured values available for differences in boron clearance between rats and humans and variability in the glomerular filtration rate (GFR) in pregnant women were used to derive chemical specific UFs. For the remaining uncertainty, newly proposed default UFs, which were derived from the latest applicable information with a probabilistic approach, and their subdivided factors for toxicokinetic and toxicodynamic variability were applied. Finally, overall UFs were calculated as 68 for rat testicular toxicity, 40 for dog testicular toxicity, 247 for mouse developmental toxicity and 78 for rat developmental toxicity. It is concluded that 0.13 mg B/kg/day is the most appropriate TDI for boron, based on rat developmental toxicity.

► We reevaluated the toxicity information for boron to derive the TDI. ► Testicular and developmental toxicity were identified as the critical endpoints. ► Measured toxicokinetic values were used to derive chemical specific UFs. ► New UFs and their subdivision were applied for the remaining uncertainty. ► It is concluded that 0.13 mg B/kg/day is the most appropriate TDI for boron.