Introducing point and deletion mutations into the P/C gene of human parainfluenza virus type 1 (HPIV1) by reverse genetics generates attenuated and efficacious vaccine candidates

The P/C gene of human parainfluenza virus type 1 (HPIV1) encodes a nested set of related accessory C proteins, C′/C/Y1/Y2, which have been shown in other paramyxoviruses to have a role in evasion of the type I interferon (IFN) response following virus infection. We previously demonstrated that a set of two amino acid substitutions, CR84G/HNT553A, and a separate amino acid substitution, CF170S, are independently attenuating for HPIV1 in African green monkeys (AGMs). However, in each case the attenuation (att) phenotype is vulnerable to reversion by a single nucleotide change back to wild type. Using reverse genetics, recombinant HPIV1 (rHPIV1) vaccine candidates were generated that were designed for increased genetic and phenotypic stability by: (i) creating a two-amino acid deletion and substitution at the site of the CF170S mutation, yielding CΔ170; (ii) introducing a six amino acid deletion in the N-terminal region of C, CΔ10–15; and (iii) combining these stable deletion mutations with the att CR84G/HNT553A mutation. The resulting rHPIV1 vaccine candidates were evaluated for attenuation in hamsters and AGMs and for immunogenicity and protective efficacy in AGMs. The CΔ10–15 mutation was attenuating in hamsters but not in AGMs, and likely will be of limited value for an HPIV1 vaccine. Conversely, the CR84G/HNT553A mutation set was attenuating in AGMs but not in hamsters. Thus, these two mutations demonstrated reciprocal host range phenotypes involving different regions of C. The CΔ170 mutation conferred a significant level of attenuation in hamsters and AGMs that closely resembled that of CF170S and will be of particular utility for vaccine development because it involves a deletion of six nucleotides rendering it highly refractory to reversion. The combination of the CR84G/HNT553A mutation set and the CΔ170 deletion mutation yielded a virus, rCR84G/Δ170HNT553A, that exhibited a satisfactory level of attenuation in hamsters and AGMs and was immunogenic and highly protective against HPIV1 wt challenge. This virus will be evaluated clinically as a live intranasal HPIV1 vaccine, one that can be further attenuated as necessary by the introduction of additional stabilized att mutations previously developed in the L protein.