Margin to tumor thickness ratio – A predictor of local recurrence and survival in oral squamous cell carcinoma

• Margin/tumor-thickness ratio serves as a predictive factor in oral squamous cell cancer.
• This ratio predicts both local control and overall survival.
• The minimum safe margin in a tumor without other adverse features can be calculated by multiplying the thickness by 0.3.

SummaryObjectivesTo assess whether small oral squamous cell carcinomas (OSCC) require the same margin clearance as large tumors. We evaluated the association between the ratio of the closest margin to tumor size (MSR) and tumor thickness (MTR) with local control and survival.Methods and methodsThe clinicopathologic and follow up data were obtained for 501 OSCC patients who had surgical resection with curative intent at our institution. MTR and MSR were computed and their associations with local control and survival were assessed using multivariable Cox-regression model. Survival curves were generated using the Kaplan–Meier method.ResultsMTR was a better predictor of disease control than MSR. MTR was a predictor of local failure (p = 0.033) and disease specific death (p = 0.038) after adjusting for perineural invasion, lymphovascular involvement, nodal status, and radiotherapy. A threshold MTR value of 0.3 was identified, above which the risk of local recurrence was low.ConclusionThe ratio of margin to tumor thickness was an independent predictor for local recurrence and disease specific death in this cohort. A MTR > 0.3 can serve as a useful tool for adjuvant therapy planning as it combines tumor thickness and margin clearance, two well established prognostic factors. The minimum safe margin can be calculated by multiplying the tumor thickness by 0.3. Further prospective studies in other institutions are warranted to confirm the prognostic utility of MTR and assess the generalizability of our threshold values.