Guided adaptive optimal decision making approach for uncertainty based watershed scale load reduction

Previous optimization-based watershed decision making approaches suffer two major limitations. First of all, these approaches generally do not provide a systematic way to prioritize the implementation schemes with consideration of uncertainties in the watershed systems and the optimization models. Furthermore, with adaptive management, both the decision environment and the uncertainty space evolve (1) during the implementation processes and (2) as new data become available. No efficient method exists to guide optimal adaptive decision making, particularly at a watershed scale. This paper presents a guided adaptive optimal (GAO) decision making approach to overcome the limitations of the previous methods for more efficient and reliable decision making at the watershed scale. The GAO approach is built upon a modeling framework that explicitly addresses system optimality and uncertainty in a time variable manner, hence mimicking the real-world decision environment where information availability and uncertainty evolve with time. The GAO approach consists of multiple components, including the risk explicit interval linear programming (REILP) modeling framework, the systematic method for prioritizing implementation schemes, and an iterative process for adapting the core optimization model for updated optimal solutions. The proposed approach was illustrated through a case study dealing with the uncertainty based optimal adaptive environmental management of the Lake Qionghai Watershed in China. The results demonstrated that the proposed GAO approach is able to (1) efficiently incorporate uncertainty into the formulation and solution of the optimization model, and (2) prioritize implementation schemes based on the risk and return tradeoff. As a result the GAO produces more reliable and efficient management outcomes than traditional non-adaptive optimization approaches.

► We propose a guided adaptive optimal decision making approach for uncertainty based watershed scale load reduction.
► The GAO approach can efficiently incorporate uncertainty into the formulation and solution of the optimization model.
► GAO produces more reliable and efficient management outcomes than traditional non-adaptive optimization approaches.