Δ14CO2 from dark respiration in plants and its impact on the estimation of atmospheric fossil fuel CO2

Radiocarbon (14C) has been widely used for quantification of fossil fuel CO2 (CO2ff) in the atmosphere and for ecosystem source partitioning studies. The strength of the technique lies in the intrinsic differences between the 14C signature of fossil fuels and other sources. In past studies, the 14C content of CO2 derived from plants has been equated with the 14C content of the atmosphere. Carbon isotopic fractionation mechanisms vary among plants however, and experimental study on fractionation associated with dark respiration is lacking. Here we present accelerator mass spectrometry (AMS) radiocarbon results of CO2 respired from 21 plants using a lab-incubation method and associated bulk organic matter. From the respired CO2 we determine Δ14Cres values, and from the bulk organic matter we determine Δ14Cbom values. A significant difference between Δ14Cres and Δ14Cbom (P < 0.01) was observed for all investigated plants, ranging from −42.3‰ to 10.1‰. The results show that Δ14Cres values are in agreement with mean atmospheric Δ14CO2 for several days leading up to the sampling date, but are significantly different from corresponding bulk organic Δ14C values. We find that although dark respiration is unlikely to significantly influence the estimation of CO2ff, an additional bias associated with the respiration rate during a plant's growth period should be considered when using Δ14C in plants to quantify atmospheric CO2ff.