The development of pragmatic skills in children after hemispherotomy: Contribution from left and right hemispheres

- Evidence of pragmatic language impairment in children after hemispherotomy
- Role of the right hemisphere in pragmatic language skills
- Links between the development of executive functions and pragmatic language
- Independence between pragmatic and receptive language impairments
- Participation of the left hemisphere at early age

PurposeHemispherotomy (H) is the standard treatment used to cure hemispheric epileptic syndromes in childhood. The postoperative linguistic profile involves hemispheric specialization processes and developmental cognitive plasticity. This research concerns pragmatic aspects of language as a tool for communication which involves both linguistic and extralinguistic communication in context. Our aim was to analyze whether any correlation exists with age at surgery and side of surgery on pragmatic skills following H.MethodForty children who underwent H (23 females, 16 right H) were evaluated at a mean age of 12.8 years (± 2.6) with two receptive tasks (oral comprehension and syntactic judgment), the Children's Communication Checklist (CCC) rating scale, and the Behavioral Rating Inventory of Executive Function (BRIEF) questionnaire in order to evaluate the role of executive functions on pragmatic skills. Children operated on before the age of 18 months were considered the “early” group (5 right H and 9 left H), while those operated on later were called the “late” group (11 right H and 15 left H).Key findingsThe whole group had significant deficits in all three measures. We demonstrated a statistically significant crossed interaction between the side of H and the age at H with pragmatic language impairments (F(1,36) = 17.48; p = .0002) and disorders in executive function (F(1,36) = 5.80; p = .021) in left early H and in right late H patients. These findings are consistent with the previous studies of pragmatic language impairments concerning adolescents and adults with right hemisphere damage and emphasize the contribution of structural language in the early stage of verbal communication.SignificanceThese results emphasize for the first time that hemispherotomized children have pragmatic language impairments that are independent of receptive language. Our findings are congruent with the recent theory on pragmatic language development in childhood with evidence of a participation of the left hemisphere at the early age followed by right hemispheric specialization and involvement of executive functions, independently of receptive language.