Use of protoplasts from paired heterogenic bacterial species to detect tin contaminants: Prospects for biosensor development

Two different bacteria gave different respiratory responses to the test analytes, tributyl tin (TBT) and cadmium as expressed by positive sigmoid responses by Halomonas sp. (slope, +1.71 [TBT]; +1.76 [Cd]) and negative sigmoid responses by Bacillus pumilis (slope, −1.06 [TBT]; −0.59 [Cd]). The EC50 values determined from Hill plots for the response of Halomonas sp. to the TBT and Cd were 1 and 8.5 mM, respectively, which were lower by a factor of 10 than the corresponding values for B. pumilis. With protoplasts of B. pumilis there was a major shift in the signal from sigmoid negative to positive with TBT (+1.35) but not Cd (−0.5), while the signals with the remaining protoplast–analyte combinations remained unchanged. For all four protoplast–analyte combinations the EC50 values were in the order of 10–100-fold lower than those for their whole cell counterparts. When other analytes were tested the protoplasts gave a similar response to tin as for TBT, but detected copper and 2,4-dichlorophenol with similar signal profiles to Cd and with lower sensitivity. The difference in signal and higher sensitivity of the two species protoplast system towards TBT/tin compared to the other analytes tested, suggests that it may feasible to develop this approach for the detection of tin residues.