Locomotive wheel failure from gauge widening/condemning: Finite element modeling and identification of underlying mechanism

Gauge change in straight plate, locomotive, railway wheels is studied using finite element analysis. The study accounts for residual stresses generated during wheel manufacturing and fitment of the wheel on locomotive axle. A validated thermal model accounting for heat loss to rail, brake blocks and ambient air is considered for accurate prediction of wheel temperatures for a given train running and braking history. Results are obtained for low- and high-friction, composite brake blocks used by Indian Railways for two limiting braking scenarios: (i) synchronized braking where braking effort is uniformly distributed on all brake blocks and (ii) independent braking where braking effort to decelerate a train is provided solely by locomotive brake blocks. Results show that bending at hub-disc interface predominantly governs the gauge change. While compressive hoop stresses in the tread region, occurring from rim heating during braking, cause gauge reduction, tensile hoop stresses in the tread region, occurring during wheel cool down cause an increase in wheel gauge. Importantly, while gauge condemning is a transient phenomenon occurring only during braking, gauge widening is “permanent” as it exists even after the wheels cool to room temperature. Allowable reduction of wheel gauge of 0.5 mm, currently used by Indian Railways, is found to be highly restrictive. In fact, in service wheel failure based on this criterion is observed in all braking scenarios considered.