Comparison of δ18O analyses on individual planktic foraminifer (Orbulina universa) shells by SIMS and gas-source mass spectrometry

The oxygen isotope (δ18O) compositions of final chamber fragments of individual shells of the planktic foraminifer Orbulina universa were measured in situ via secondary ion mass spectrometry (SIMS) and by traditional gas-source mass spectrometry (GSMS) entailing acid digestion of sampled calcite. The paired SIMS-GSMS analyses were performed on final chamber fragments of fossil shells taken from the top of a sediment core (Holocene) as well as shells grown in laboratory culture. Multiple iterations of SIMS-GSMS analyses were conducted on final chamber fragments treated with a variety of cleaning protocols. The series of paired analyses yielded an average SIMS-GSMS δ18O offset (Δ18OSIMS-GSMS) of −0.9 ± 0.1‰ (±2 SE). The volume of material analyzed in 10-μm SIMS spots is ~105 times smaller than that analyzed by GSMS; hence, the extent to which these Δ18OSIMS-GSMS values represent real differences in analyte vs. instrumental factors remains unclear. Possible contributing factors to the SIMS-GSMS δ18O difference include sample-standard mismatch by SIMS, differences in standardization of SIMS and GSMS, and non-calcite contaminants in samples. Although the two datasets are consistently offset, SIMS values reproduce inter-shell δ18O variability delineated by shell fragment GSMS values. This strong positive covariance proved useful for bringing the two datasets into agreement (i.e. Δ18OSIMS-GSMS = 0), and confirms that SIMS-based foraminifer δ18O values record changes in calcification temperature and/or δ18O of seawater. Whether shells of foraminifer taxa with differing microcrystalline structures, chemical composition, and/or preservation histories register a similar Δ18OSIMS-GSMS value is a subject of ongoing testing.