Comparative study of resistivity characteristics between transparent conducting AZO and GZO thin films for use at high temperatures

This paper compares in detail the resistivity behavior of transparent conducting Al-doped and Ga-doped ZnO (AZO and GZO) thin films for use in an air environment at high temperatures. AZO and GZO thin films with thicknesses in the range from approximately 30 to 100 nm were prepared on glass substrates at a temperature of 200 °C by rf superimposed dc or conventional dc magnetron sputtering deposition, pulsed laser deposition or vacuum arc plasma evaporation techniques. In heat-resistance tests, the resistivity was measured both before and after heat tests for 30 min in air at a temperature up to 400 °C. The resistivity stability of AZO thin films was found to be always lower than that of GZO thin films prepared with the same thickness under the same deposition conditions, regardless of the deposition technique. However, the resistivity of all AZO and GZO thin films prepared with a thickness above approximately 100 nm was stable when heat tested at a temperature up to approximately 250 °C. It was found that the resistivity stability in both GZO and AZO thin films is dominated by different mechanisms determined by whether the thickness is below or above approximately 50 nm. With thicknesses above approximately 100 nm, the increase in resistivity found in GZO and AZO films after heat testing at a temperature up to 400 °C exhibited different characteristics that resulted from a variation in the behavior of Hall mobility.