Temporal and spatial scales of geomorphic adjustments to reduced competency following flow regulation in bedload-dominated systems

Because of the combined effects of reduced sediment transport capacity and competency following flow regulation, morphological changes are expected to occur in channels downstream from dams and, specifically, at tributary junctions where local inputs of water and sediment occur. Using a combination of historical aerial photographs, mainstem- and tributary-channel pebble counts, and HEC-RAS flow modeling for two watersheds in south-central VT, one unregulated and the other regulated since 1961, we document the time series of post-regulation channel narrowing and associated bar growth due to the influx of tributary sediment. Channel adjustments at regulated tributary junctions have been significant in ca. 50 years following impoundment, with channels downstream of the confluences narrowing over 15% after an initial ca. 20-year lag before the onset of accelerated narrowing. Moreover, flow modeling suggests that downstream of regulated confluences, the modern median grain size (d50) along the channel bed is immobile. No significant channel narrowing has occurred either above or below unregulated tributary junctions or on the mainstem upstream of regulated confluences. However, greater channel sediment fining is observed upstream of regulated confluences than above unregulated confluences. Thus, the primary mode of mainstem channel adjustment differs up- and downstream of regulated tributaries. These confluence effects have occurred where the tributary drainage area is only 0.2 times that of the mainstem, well below the threshold ratio of 0.6 required for significant geomorphic effects at unregulated confluences, highlighting the geomorphic scale shift of dams. Lastly, we evaluate the downstream length required for a river to recover from the impacts of impoundment and demonstrate that even distal locations are impacted by flow regulation. Unlike the impacts of flow regulation in the western US where channel incision and bar erosion predominate following impoundment, we find that in situations where bed incision is minimal and where sediment loads are low but bed caliber high, bar growth and channel narrowing are significant adjustments at tributary junctions following impoundment. Therefore, at our sites the effects of dams on reduced competency may be more profound than on reduced sediment transport capacity, highlighting the importance of geologic and geomorphic settings in understanding fluvial responses to impoundment.